Introduction
Mike Spicer [00:02] It's called a roadmap, and it may well be the biggest transfer of power and resources out of Whitehall in a generation. But where does it actually end? With mayors setting taxes, or just sharing out the Treasury's [taxes]?
David Marlow [00:14] And at the end of the road, will mayors actually be able to deliver inclusive, sustainable growth and development for their geographies? I'm David Marlow…
Mike Spicer [00:23] …and I'm Mike Spicer. Welcome to LED Confidential, the podcast that tries to lift the lid on those intractable, enduring challenges facing those of us working in and on local economic development and placemaking today.
What the roadmap actually does
David Marlow [00:36]
So, Mike, the roadmap came out with the Budget on the 28th of October, and as you've already said, it was billed as the biggest transfer of power and resources out of Whitehall in a generation. In brief, from 2027, mayors get 20% of locally retained business rates and 20% of its growth in place of their investment funds and capacity funding. Councils move towards keeping at least 70% of business rates by the end of the decade. Every strategic authority can introduce a visitor levy. There's a £1.5 billion borrowing facility for mayors, nine business rate retention zones, and from April 2028, every mayor gets a share of basic rate income tax.
That's all real, but read it as a roadmap, and you need to get through Spending Review 2027 before we can discern what the destination is going to be, because the pence rate, the starting allocations, the growth share, the taper, the floor and the resets are all left to next year's Spending Review. Mayors never get to set a rate or a threshold. Council Tax isn't reformed. Land value capture is only something to, in inverted commas, "explore". The roadmap doesn't say whether capital moves to assigned taxes or stays as Whitehall grant. And beyond 2030, further reforms are under review.
I guess what it does describe is tax sharing: a nationally set tax, assigned by where people live, split between places, and evened out by a formula indexed to average growth across the mayoral authorities. It's close to how I understand Germany or Spain fund their regions, rather than Scotland or Wales. Power to vary rates: on the OECD's measure of local tax autonomy, it would sit at the bottom. The centre sets the rate and the base and shares the money, and the scale stays modest.
On my rough estimates, by 2030 Greater Manchester's mayor controls about one and a half percent of the city region's economy, the East Midlands rather less. The Scottish and Welsh governments each spend around a third of theirs. It isn't like for like, because Scotland and Wales run health and schools, but it puts this "biggest transfer" headline in proportion. Much of a mayor's 2030 budget will be labelled as their own taxes, but they set the rate on almost none of it. So is it a staging post to genuine fiscal devolution, or something else altogether? Where are you coming from on it?
Realpolitik and the public services question
Mike Spicer [03:18]
So, firstly, I don't take the glass half full interpretation that because the fiscal roadmap doesn't end with as much local control over raising revenue as in some other OECD countries, it should go much further. I think that ignores the realpolitik of reform, because we're moving away from funding competitions and centrally designed pots, or settlements as we might now call them, for financing LED, to a system of tax assignment: sharing income tax, retention of business rates.
It isn't just about sharpening incentives and increasing local accountability around local growth. It also takes us into the knotty realm of public service delivery because, of course, the taxes that are being reassigned are currently used to fund them at the national level.
So I think this is much more politically sensitive than LED funding mechanisms could ever be, and I think this aspect of fiscal devolution hasn't been explored as much as it should be. If I can have a slight dig at my own profession, I think it's often underplayed quite a lot by people who like to talk about this stuff.
We shouldn't underestimate it, because it raises some really big questions. Which elements of public service delivery should be devolved along with tax revenue? How do you balance the need to maintain incentives to grow the tax base with the reality that areas differ hugely in their starting points? And can there be a culture shift in public attitudes away from expecting national conformity to accepting local differences and frictions?
So my take is that the roadmap as it is now is a sensible answer to those questions, based on where we're starting from. But I think it's highly likely that we'll revisit it as we move along. I don't think we'll just leave it until 2030 and nothing more will be said on it. The history of fiscal devolution in the last 12 months has been that the ambition around it has increased quite substantially. So I don't think this is the last word. I think it'll be revisited, probably on an annual basis with Budgets, and of course every three years with the Spending Review, and I think we will see it become more radical between now and 2030.
But in terms of where we are today, as of 2026, I don't believe it's politically sensible or realistic, or even deliverable, to ramp up the radical as of today. I think it will happen over time as cultures and attitudes shift. It's a journey that we're going on. That's my take on it, David.
Preparing for Spending Review 2027
David Marlow [06:13]
Well, look, I'll give you that. But as you had a dig at our profession, and given the point you've made, if you are working with our profession, let's say towards Spending Review 27, which is actually very imminent, what sorts of discussions would you be provoking about the destinations underpinning the progression that you've spoken about?
Mike Spicer [06:40]
I think you do have to look at the core issues about how your economic strategy affects the local tax base. If we're talking about 2030, that's four years away. We are going to have a new crop of Local Growth Plans. We are going to have a new crop of skills strategies, and also other sub-apex strategies relating to different areas of economic development, from labour market to innovation and all the rest of it.
So I think you need to start thinking about how those strategies affect the tax base: where the programmes increase employment and resident earnings, how different growth scenarios translate into public revenues. I think that's something that is missing, actually, from Local Growth Plans. You've got to start thinking about those questions, and about how you can build the capacity to think about them, because they are going to become a feature of local economic development in the decade ahead.
Economic inactivity and the capacity premium
David Marlow [08:03]
Yeah. One of the things that I'm really interested in was the choice, if you like, of resident-based basic rate earnings, and whether it will actually change behaviour in terms of the priority given to one of the standards of this podcast: economic inactivity. Because, in a sense, there is a real incentive to get people onto the tax ladder, up to the point of however the system is designed. So I did wonder whether, for example, you might have an even greater shift towards addressing economic inactivity vis-à-vis, if you like, knowledge-led, high-value growth, where there won't necessarily be any local premium in terms of the places where it goes.
The other thing I was going to throw into the pot is that it does seem to me that there is going to be a huge premium on the maturity and capacity of the mayoral strategic authorities to actually deliver the sort of responsiveness to the system redesign that you're talking about. And I do worry about how less mature strategic authorities, and in particular non-mayoral strategic authorities, will fare in the sort of debates that you're talking about.
Mike Spicer [09:36]
We've touched on this a little bit in a previous episode, around the placement programme for civil servants within mayoral strategic authorities, and I wouldn't be surprised if you start to see that grow in size. My interactions with mayoral strategic authorities would suggest that where they have requested additional capacity from the central government civil service, it has been around those areas of policy that are becoming devolved, using that tactically to build up some capacity in that area. But I think, longer term, the sort of capacity that those organisations need is perhaps less around policy and more around operational capability. That's the harder thing.
Modelling 2030 budgets: a plea to listeners
David Marlow [10:29]
Yeah, I'd like to almost finish on that point, because the last point I was going to make was that I would really like to see some model sources and application of funds for strategic authority areas, let's say in 2030. As preparation for this podcast, I tried to do one for Greater Manchester and for the East Midlands, and it is really interesting in terms of sources and applications when you put together an income tax basic rate assignment, visitor levy, business rates, then whatever other assumptions you have around precepts and so on, and then you look at the issues you raised on the public services that those are meant to buy.
Mine was very back of the envelope, but Greater Manchester looks very different to the East Midlands. And then there are areas which won't even be as established as the East Midlands by 2030. So, a plea to our listeners: if you're doing something like a sources and application of funds for a 2030 mayoral strategic authority, we'd be really interested to hear from you and discuss it.
Closing
Mike Spicer [11:37]
That probably draws us to a close, David, given our time constraints. To our listeners, I hope you enjoyed our brief look at the fiscal devolution roadmap. We'd like to hear from you about it. If you were writing the last page of the roadmap, for example, let's use that scenario, what would your favoured destination be? And has your area started modelling what the new system means for the growth plan? Do share your suggestions for how we might get into these issues in greater depth, with guest or themed episode suggestions. As ever, you can connect with us on all things LED Confidential through our website, which is www.ledconfidential.co.uk. Connect with our bonus material there and send us your suggestions for future episodes. Till the next time.